1.5 million yearly

That’s the number of legal immigrants entering our country, according to a new report by the Center for Immigration Studies.

Ever since I first started blogging — and blogging mostly about immigration, 10 years ago, this number has been reported as 1.5 million legal immigrants yearly. I’ve been citing that number for ages, and yet it seemed for the longest time to make little impression on a lot of people. Even now it doesn’t seem to sink in with a certain percentage of people — though the rise of Donald Trump seems to indicate that people are finally ‘getting it’, getting an idea of the gravity of the situation.

If it’s explained in terms of saying that 30 million legal immigrants have been added over the last 20 years, that should impress most people. And that’s not counting the mostly uncountable illegals, who certainly outnumber the legal ones by quite a margin.

Yet there are still the stubborn people who repeat the mantra “…as long as they come in legally, as long as they obey the laws, as long as they go by our rules…” but is it true that the tens of millions are not a problem as long as they obey the letter of the law?

My answer is: it’s not true, no matter how many times the pollyannas and the immigration enthusiasts repeat it. The pro-immigrant pollyannas and romanticists say that ‘legal immigrants are the good ones, because they respect the law and they are willing to follow procedures and learn English and assimilate”, and all the rest of the comforting platitudes.

Another favorite claim is that the legal ones are a better class of people, hard-working and often better-qualified to be productive citizens. All evidences are that there is little difference, given that by far most immigrants are from Third World countries, and given that legal or illegal, they often have little education and low skills, or even if educated, little fluency in English or familiarity with our system, our way of life here, and our society’s morals and standards. How many news stories have we read where some immigrant (legal or not) commits a crime and pleads unfamiliarity with our culture and its moral rules or legal system? Personally I’ve heard quite a few of these stories.

How much longer can our country continue to absorb a million and a half legal immigrants — not to mention the uncounted millions of illegal ones — plus the ‘chain migration’ of all their relatives, in-laws, and relatives of in-laws? Whole colonies have grown up in this country which started with a few people as the ‘seeds’ and ended up populating whole neighborhoods or small towns. Given enough time, that’s what happens.

Immigration has to be de-romanticized, stripped of its maudlin mystique — the ”nation of immigrants”, the Statue of Liberty, Ellis Island, and all the rest of it. Most of my readers are aware, but there are still too many people who see immigration as something to get all misty-eyed and maudlin about, something to occasion a feeling of patriotic fervor.  Yet at some point even these people need to see that it’s not what we need in 21st century (post)-America. Sometimes people need a splash of cold water to wake them up. I don’t know if this latest report will do that but sooner or later the sentimental illusions need to give way to reality.


2 thoughts on “1.5 million yearly

  1. Thanks for refocusing our attention on the number of legal immigrants, VA. Trump pushes attention to the Wall and to illegals. He is almost the new version of the Lou Dobbs meme, illegal bad, legal good. I won’t speculate, in this paragraph, on whether both are intentionally set to mislead us.

    If the population is 300 million, and people live 75 years, then 4 million die a year. So 1.5 million legal entering a year means 2.5 million births is the steady state. Even if population is increasing, the substitution effect pressure is still measured this way. If we take 4 – 1.5 = 2.5, we get a ratio of 2.5/4 = .625. So our replacement allocation is almost down to one half.

    If you look at city-data.com by county, they have charts of never married for men and women as of age brackets. Typically for women aged 25 to 30, half or more are never married. In New York County = Manhattan it is about 85% as it is in Boston = Suffolk County. Even rural counties like Lancaster County PA are about 55%. Age 30 to 35 is over 50 percent in Manhattan = New York County.

    If women who marry after 30 have 1 child, and those before have 2, and these are half each, you get 3 children out of 4 counting the men, or a ratio of 3/4 = .75. Throw in some never having children and you get down to the .625.

    If you use 1.1 million green cards, round to 1 million and divide by 4, you get 1/4. So the replacement ratio is 3/4 which matches the simpler case of half women have 2 children and half have one child.

    Data already show fewer Whites under age 20 in most counties in the US. There is a map going around showing this. This matches the above reasoning.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply to bonnyblue1607 Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s