Who said “America: love it or…”

What with all the furor over the President’s comments — suggesting that those who ‘hate’ our country might like to leave — those of us who were around in the 1970s likely remember the saying ‘America: love it or leave it.’

That phrase seems to be along the same line as what the President said, but somehow I don’t remember that older phrase stirring up such a hornets’ nest of anger and invective. It seems we’ve changed since those relatively peaceful days of the 1970s. I seem to remember that later, during the Reagan years, the phrase ‘love it or leave it‘ enjoyed a certain popularity, though the usual legions of the disgruntled may have muttered and grumbled about ‘jingoism’ or something.

People back then, even the leftists, hadn’t yet developed the habit of throwing the ‘r’-word around with such profligacy. It’s hard to imagine it was ever like that in America.

Incidentally, it seems that the phrase ‘America: love it or leave it‘ was coined by old-time radio reporter Walter Winchell, back in 1940, before Pearl Harbor and our entry into World War II.

The slogan persisted and was revived during the Vietnam War era, as a response to the far-left’s constant agitprop.

It may be that the President’s words were a little more incendiary than the Winchell slogan, but it seems that he has some ‘Wormtongues” close to him who are trying to induce him to recant what he said. I think that would be a mistake and it wouldn’t appease those who say they are offended. Apologies in cases like these appear as weakness.

And if any of us were resident in a foreign country whose people and whose policies we harshly criticized, I think we’d expect to be given a rough reception by the leaders and citizens of said country. And in the first place, why would anybody want to move to a country which they saw as ‘racist’ and oppressive? That’s the height of irrationality, or sheer perversity. Yet it seems that many of our new ‘neighbors’ and newly elected officials don’t like us very much, despite their determination to settle down amongst us deplorable people. I find that really odd, yet nobody ever asks the obvious question ‘why’? I suppose it would be too politically incorrect. Truth and frankness are dangerous these days.

4 thoughts on “Who said “America: love it or…”

  1. “ if any of us were resident in a foreign country whose people and whose policies we harshly criticized, I think we’d expect to be given a rough reception by the leaders and citizens of said country. ”

    It’s because these intruders KNOW they have sizable support among the native population to provide them cover. They are secure and have no fear of being driven out as they ought to be.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I was once told, by a close female relative, that “you should take your own advice and ‘love it or leave it’ if you think America is so bad.” My recollection is that this outburst of hers was brought about when I complained about ‘Weimerican degeneracy’ or something of that nature. When I protested her claim that this was my advice to others who complain about America with a denial that I had never once uttered the phrase that I could recall, and challenged her to cite one instance – one conversation – she knew of in which I had used that phrase, she thought on it for awhile and finally admitted she couldn’t remember any. I of course quickly pointed out that she had made the fundamental error of projecting onto me what she had heard stated by others she deems my ideological brethren. Namely Right-Liberals, otherwise known as “mainstream conservatives.” I also pointed out that were I to ever employ that phrase (which I probably wouldn’t, but anyway), I would do so with people who have one foot in America and the other in their country of origin; never with persons with deep roots here.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Terry, good point. Those who have an equivocal loyalty to this country, or who talk about fleeing to their grandparents’ country or whatever should make up their minds where their loyalties lie, and to which people they belong. Maybe for some, blood calls and they feel as though they belong elsewhere, where it’s ”better” but in these times a firm committment it necessary, no waffling. As for some of us with deep roots here we have no other country, unlike those who have the luxury of ‘two countries’. Or more.
    This is it for us.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s