American Reconstruction — circa 1919

When we hear or read the term ‘Reconstruction’, those of us from the South at least, tend to think of the process that was inflicted on the former CSA, but in 1919 or so, the R-word of that day was more likely to refer to the planned process of re-making not just the world map post WWI, but remaking the minds and hearts of the former combatant nations, specifically the Western/European world.

Nowadays many people, lacking a good education in 20th century history, think that the Left’s current offensive is peculiar to our day, whereas when we look at books of the early 20th century we find that the Left was already barking mad back then. For example; there were leftist parties in America which were very much active , and in the wake of WWI there were violent episodes, such as incidents involving the out-of-control Industrial Workers of the World (IWW, also known as ‘Wobblies’). In a shocking episode, IWW members lynched and castrated a military veteran, and killed four other men in a separate shooting episode, in Centralia, Washington. The Pacific Northwest has long been a hotbed of this kind of fanaticism. Of course current sources say that IWW violence is a ”myth” but then myths don’t kill people.

The antifas, aggressive and brutish as they are, are kiddies compared to their counterparts of a hundred years ago. This is not to downplay the malice of the antifas but to remind us that the violence and unrest are not peculiar to our troubled time, but another instance of a recurrent, chronic phenomenon.

The unrest of the post-WWI era also manifested in the form of — well, manifestos. Lost of rhetoric appeared involving how humanity must learn to live together in harmony, or else — or else humanity would destroy itself in rampant senseless wars. The answer, according to our betters, who were writing book upon book urging peace at all costs, was for us all to transcend nationalism and learn to join together.

A few examples of the many books that appeared circa 1919 were: Reconstructing America (subtitle: Sociologically and Economically) by one Benjamin J. Rosenthal, and another tome, also called Reconstructing America, subtitled ‘Our Next Big Job‘. It was a compilation of essays by ‘respected’ invidivuals including Woodrow Wilson, Paul Warburg, and John D. Rockefeller Jr., From the introduction:

“We are in the throes of a new order, conscious of a new spirit of toleration and mutual interest…

Yet another book, by Cecil Fairfield Lavell, also printed in 1919, also used the word ‘Reconstruction’ in its title – (Reconstruction and National Life). Among the ideas promoted in that book were the ‘fusion’ of different ethnic and racial groups, suggesting that this would be the best answer, a sure deterrent to future conflicts. Another odd idea there: that intensified nationalism, though feared by the intelligentsia, might in fact fuel internationalism. I suppose this meant that they thought people were so war-weary (understandably so, after the horrors of WWI) that they would reject nationalism. Or were they intending to try a kind of aversion therapy by allowing nationalism to go to such excesses that people would reject it in favor of the ‘One World’ nostrum?

Shades of the Kalergists.

In all my reading of old books in the last year or two, focusing on the WWI era and earlier, it becomes obvious that the situation in which we find ourselves is not of recent origin; it’s been brewing for at least the better part of a century, and much longer than that if you go back at least to the era of the rise of the Jacobins. Yet we can only seem to see causes in much more recent times.

But these things, having deeper roots than we have imagined, will be harder to deal with if we don’t consider their long-established presence in our country and in Europe.

3 thoughts on “American Reconstruction — circa 1919

  1. I suppose it’s heartening in a way to know that some of what we are facing is nothing new under the sun. However, it’s disheartening too as some of it has been going for over a century. I went to a decent parochial grade school and a very good religious private high school. We were never taught in depth about World War I or the anarchist violence that followed afterwards (and I graduated high school in the mid-2000’s). I do recall via VDare that the reason quotas were signed into law in 1924 was due to anarchist violence.

    I shudder to think what it’ll be like when the last of your generation VA is gone…as you are the last to remember America pre-’65 (i.e. Hart-Cellar). As much as I like reading Vox’s blog, what does steam me (an early Millenial born in the mid-’80s) is the gaping historical ignorance. Does he not realize that the voting age was not lowered to 18 until after Hart-Cellar had been signed into law? The earliest Boomers were born in 1946 making them a wopping 19 years old and unable to vote when Hart-Cellar became law. Just my 2¢.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Hi Überdeplorable, thanks for your comments. Yes, it is sad, almost criminal really, that the educational system doesn’t teach about some of these important events, like the anarchist violence you mention post WWI, or the Bonus Army and the violence associated with that situation.
    Though I feel that I did get a good education there were gaps in my learning that I’ve had to fill in as an adult, and even now as I go through these old books I am learning new things.
    The point you made about the voting age for the dread Boomer generation is something that some people don’t realize. it wasn’t until what, the 1972 election that most Baby Boomers were eligible to vote. By that time things were already pretty far gone, and the older generations were at the helm then, not the young Boomers of that time.
    By the way i’ve almost come to loathe the word ‘boomer’, so thoroughly has it become tainted. It seems like a vile word now, because people always use it to express loathing and derision.
    As you’re a millennial — I hope you understand that if I say anything negative about your age group it’s not personal at all. I know I have some millennial readers (among my select few faithful) and I know there are some intelligent and thoughtful people in your age group. Every age group has a variety of kinds of people and I appreciate all my readers and especially those who leave comments, well-written ones.


  3. bonnieblue1607, Would you be able to recommend some books? I’ve been researching the WWII era, but I would be interested in your recommendations of books regarding the WWI period and its effects on America.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s